Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 4

The woolly mammoth is a prehistoric animal that has been extinct for thousands of years. Upon first reading about this forum, the first question that popped into my head was: how can scientists recreate such a massive and extinct animal and reintroduce it into an entirely new ecosystem? Research to bring the woolly mammoth back began in 2013 when almost an entire woolly mammoth was dug up the permafrost of Siberia. From carbon dating, it was discovered that the woolly mammoth roamed the earth about 40,000 years ago. From the uncovered woolly mammoth, scientists extracted a  DNA sample from the blood of the woolly mammoth in order to use gene splicing to create a mammoth-elephant hybrid. They then used CRISPR to isolate specific genes from the woolly mammoth DNA and integrated the segment into the genome of an Asian Elephant.

One reason scientists are looking to bring the woolly mammoth back would be because of its ability to combat global warming. Large amounts of carbon are trapped in the permafrost of the Siberian Plains, and as the tundra melts this carbon is released into the atmosphere. Integrating the woolly mammoth would introduce more herbivores that could feed on the land. Feeding on the land would expose the land to the cold air and allow the land to stay more frozen for a longer time which prevents the release of carbon into the atmosphere. However, the only disadvantage I can think of is that these animals have been extinct for so long that they may be unable to adapt to the evolved environment or impact the native species's ability to survive. 

I think a lot of controversy surrounds this type of scientific experimentation. Critics of the woolly mammoth recreation argue that geneticists are playing god by reintroducing extinct species into the current environment. Despite ethical concerns, I think the reintroduction of the woolly mammoth could have a really helpful positive impact on undoing some of the harms surrounding global warming. I do think this could be done with other species if there are currently living species that are similar to the extinct species like the elephant is to the woolly mammoth, but again this raises several ethical questions. 

History (January 22, 2019). Are Scientists on the Verge of Resurrecting the Wholly Mammoth? Retrieved from https://www.history.com/news/wooly-mammoth-resurrection-cloning-genesis

National Geographic (July 8, 2017). We Could Resurrect the Woolly Mammoth. Here’s How.Retrieved from https://www.nationalgeographic.com/news/2017/07/woolly-mammoths-extinction-cloning-genetics/

Bringing Back Woolly Mammoths. (2018, May 30). Retrieved from https://www.pbs.org/wgbh/nova/video/bringing-back-woolly-mammoths/

428 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

by Deleted user -
Hi Ansleigh! I enjoyed reading your post! I think you are right that it's really difficult to predict how reintroducing wooly mammoth might affect the environment and other species, and whether or not the mammoths themselves would be able to survive. There are so many variables involved in ecosystems! That said, it would be really cool to be able to resurrect extinct species. This whole thing feels so surreal…
What do you think the ethical questions of resurrecting other species are? Do you think it might be easier to resurrect extinct species that don’t require a womb to live in?

100 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

by Deleted user -
Hi Ansleigh! I think your post was super informative. I really enjoyed reading about all genetic techniques that could be used to bring the woolly mammoth back to life and some of the possible benefits of its ‘rebirth’. When I was doing my research, I also came across the point that the woolly mammoth could help with global warming as well, and I find that comforting. I do agree with you on the point about difficulty adapting back to the current lifestyle. I think that since they became extinct 4,000 years ago, the earth has evolved and so many aspects have changed in terms of climate and temperature that I think the woolly mammoth might struggle trying to get acquainted with the ‘new’ world. I do agree with you about the God-aspect of geneticists and how it adds controversy around this idea. I think that bringing the woolly mammoth back would be beneficial for global warming, but there are also ethical concerns about manipulating species and playing ‘god’ that need to be considered.

173 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

by Deleted user -
Hi Ansleigh! I really liked your post a lot and appreciated how informative it was! It was also very well written. I agree whole heartedly with you when you say that since the wooly mammoth has been extinct for so long, they may have trouble adapting to the evolved environment. Won't it be too hot for them? I also agree that bringing back the wooly mammoth will be very beneficial in they being able to undo what our world has done but I also don't know if I like the idea of manipulating genes and species. They became extinct for a reason right?

103 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Bringing the Woolly Mammoth Back to Life

by Deleted user -
Hey Ansleigh! I really like how you brought up the fact that people think scientists could be “playing God” by bringing back extinct species. I did not really think about this, but if an animal went extinct, there must be some reason they went extinct, right? Whether that’s the fact that the species was unable to adapt to a changing climate or anything else, bringing them back has to have some consequences. For example, if the species went extinct because they were unable to adapt to a changing climate, what makes scientists think that the animal will be okay and able to survive in our current climate, especially since it is rapidly changing. There are a lot of ethical concerns that I never considered that you make a good point by bringing up. I do think however that you’re right when you say despite these concerns there are many advantages, specifically involving global warming.

154 words