Woolly Mammoth

Woolly Mammoth

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 4

    The woolly mammoth is an ancient species of elephants that have been extinct for thousands of years. And for many years, people have been digging up remains of these animals in the ice, and they can find tusk up to an actual mammoth carcass. In 2013 a team from Russia had found almost an entire mammoth carcass that had blood oozing out of it. They had used carbon dating to find out that this woolly mammoth had lived 40,000 years ago. With this now in hand, the research had begun to try and bring back a woolly mammoth. And with this, they used the DNA in the CRISPR to isolate specific genes and then integrate it into the DNA of an Asian Elephant, which is the closest living relative to the wooly mammoth. 

    The video gives reasons that scientists want to bring back the woolly mammoth, and it’s to fights climate change. They say the reasoning for this would be is because locked in the deep permafrost of the artic there are greenhouse gases that escape when the ice melts, and it is so much that it would speed up climate change in the world. They say that mammoths can help with this because they are herbivores that can strip big fields of greenery. And since this happens, this allows grass, which is the fastest-growing plant to grow back more. Also, when it snows, and there is ice on the ground, the mammoths move the snow to get to the grass, which then exposes the ground to the cold air, which keeps the permafrost frozen. Also, if you do have a hybrid of mammoth and Asian elephants, then it could save the species. These are the advantage but let’s talk about the disadvantages. 

    I think one would be if you bring another animal into the environment, it could cause the extinction or movement of other plant-eaters. I say this because you are putting another animal in the environment, which can have severe problems for the ecosystem. Another reason is that there are no predators in today’s world that could take down a mammoth, which would move their food source to the other herbivores in the environment. This could cause a severe decrease in the number of species that are targeted by predators. These are disadvantages I think there would be if wooly mammoths were brought back to life. 

    I think that if it can be done for a woolly mammoth, then it definitely can be done for other animals. The reason I believe this is because the mammoth that was found was over 40,000 years old, and I think if we wanted to try with newer species that have gone extinct or are endangered, it could benefit the species as a whole. Just thinking about if this type of research and experiment is successful, we could do so many things for endangered to the point where they aren’t endangered. 

References:

https://youtu.be/CQ078VfQXQI

https://www.history.com/news/wooly-mammoth-resurrection-cloning-genesis

499 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Woolly Mammoth

by Deleted user -
Hi Slade! I enjoyed reading your post. You make a very good point that uncontrolled herbivores can strip grass quickly, possibly taking away a valuable food source from other herbivores. Plus, we don't know how fast wooly mammoths can reproduce--we're only guessing based on their relation to elephants, and our data regarding elephant reproduction is significantly affected by poaching, habitat loss, and other externalities. We also don't know much about their behavior... All of this could lead to unforeseen ecological consequences. I also liked your point on resurrecting other species. I wonder if it would end up being easier and less expensive to save endangered species using this method, or if it would be easier to use other methods like reducing the resources we use.

125 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Woolly Mammoth

by Deleted user -
Hey Slade, I enjoyed reading your post! I agree with you that imposing a new population of herbavoires could shift the ecosystem in ways we have not accounted for. While we know the behavior of our own elephants today, we do not necessarily know the behavior of wolly mammoths. They are a whole new species after all. But, I agree with your assessment that this could be used on recently extinct or endangered animals better. Because we know more about these more recent species, it would not be as big of a gamble to reintroduce these animals back into the system. Although, if they went extinct once, we must fix the reason they left in the first place. Just replacing animals without fixing their homes is going to create a very big mess if we don't think through all of the implications. I think that using CRISPR has wonderful advantages, but this seems to be using all of the technology for none of the benefit.

165 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Woolly Mammoth

by Deleted user -
Hey Slade, I really enjoyed your discussion forum on bringing back the Woolly Mammoth. I agree with you completely about the effect it could have on other animals in the area. I think there is a possibility that it could cause the extinction of other species in the area. I also think you make a very good point about the lack of predators for the Mammoth. There could be a lack of population control for the mammoths and if they begin to reproduce at a rapid rate, it would have an even greater effect on the other species in that area. I also think the part about the carcass that has been dead for 40,000 years and is still oozing blood is insane. That is an incredible long time.

129 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Woolly Mammoth

by Deleted user -
Hey Slade, I agree with everything you say on this post and you make some great points. I especially agree with the statement about messing with the ecosystem if the mammoths are brought back. I believe that there is a delicate balance in the ecosystem and bringing in another variable could completely mess it up. I also agree and stated in my forum that the huge beasts now have no natural predators to keep their numbers in check which can lead to massive overpopulation. A question I do have for you is if you think if this can be done for a woolly mammoth should the same techniques be applied to other extinct animals or animals on the endangered list or should we just leave nature alone?

127 words