Week 6 Discussion

Week 6 Discussion

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 5

          Ramanujan said, “no text is original, yet no telling is a mere retelling –and the story has no closure, although it may be enclosed in a text” (46). Based on the reading, depending on the region, the Ramayana presents various beginnings, endings, messages, and character attributes/characteristics. For example, in some versions, such as “the Adbhula Ramayana and the Tamil story of Satakantharavana even give Sita a heroic character…Rama cannot handle this new menace, so it is Sita who goes to war and slays the new demon (43-44). Sita? In Valmiki’s version, the one we read, she is a submissive puppet of Rama, but she is definitely not in these versions. Additionally, a regional version considers “Sita as unfaithful…she is seduced both by Ravana and by Laksmana” (44). According to Sita Sings the Blues, Sita has multiple names, such as “Janaki and Vaidehi.” Also, she is more respected in this movie than in certain versions of the Ramayana. It presents a feminist perspective by focusing on the trials of Sita. It even includes “Sita” in the title. For example, the modern couple represents Sita and Rama. “Nina” or “Sita” is infatuated by “Dave.” She even follows him to India, like Sita followed Rama into the wilderness. Dave doesn’t provide her with attention, though, and treats her poorly. Eventually, they break up, but, in the end, she ultimately appears content.

           Other variations include the distinctions of and opposing outlooks on characters, like Ravana, Hanuman, and Rama. Even endings vary amongst the ones “in Sanskrit and in the other Indian languages” (39) versions, such as “one ends with the return of Rama and Sita to Ayodhya” and in the other “Rama hears Sita slandered as a woman who lived in Ravana’s grove, and in the name of his reputation as a king…he banishes her to the forest” (39). Every Ramayana has unique qualities, such as in the movie, one shadow puppet narrator informs the others of Hanuman being an incarnation of Siva. They were unaware of this. Possibly, their regional version didn’t mention this feature. Also, this version includes the ending where Sita is banished, which is a version not applied by all.

          Overall, Sita Sings the Blues depicts various images of the popular story itself, such as the different depictions of Rama and Sita. One version of Sita is a cartoon jazz singer and another is Nina. I believe this correlates with the different regional versions of the Ramayana. Each version is quite unique.


416 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 6 Discussion

by Deleted user -
Sam, I do not know about you, but I found the references to character representation fascinating throughout the text. To think that Ravana could be worshiped and in some cultures Sita is the hero is astounding. I wonder how these stories mutated overtime through oral traditions into what they are today. I enjoyed the engagement with the Rama and Sita narratives in Sita Sings the Blues, too. The threefold narrative runs parallel to the understanding of regional variation. Not only does the plight of Sita come into focus through Nina and Dave's relationship, but also through the academic dialogue from the narrators and eerily well fitting blues music score. The creative lengths people go to in the pursuit of portraying this narrative are really incredible.

125 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 6 Discussion

by Collin Cortinas -
Sam,
This is some good stuff! There are many interesting references throughout the different depictions of the characters, and it really shook my understanding of the story that we read. I found the film to be a very interesting exploration of the different ideas and interpretations of the text, and I really like what you have to say about it.

60 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 6 Discussion

by Deleted user -

I think the first quote is very powerful because it shows what happens when there is a retelling of stories and when there is a writing and reading of the stories as well.

33 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 6 Discussion

by Deleted user -
In Sita Sings the Blues, I found the argument in favor of Ravana not being this awful villain, but to have some redeeming qualities to be interesting. One of the narrators is trying to make a case for her. He did abduct her and yet in some way he kind of showed her more respect than Rama.

57 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 6 Discussion

by Deleted user -
Hey Sam! You made really great points in this post. I was also surprised that the other narrators did not know that Hanuman was an incarnation of Siva, but it made sense once I read Ramanujan. I like how you pointed out the feminist interpretations of the Ramayana. The simple fact that "Sita" is in the title of the movie highlights the importance of female characters which are often overlooked. Nina's contentment at the end of the movie surprised me at first, but in the context of the Ramayana, this contentment depicts a version of Sita who's life is not dependent on Rama.

103 words