challenging the system

challenging the system

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 2

As is with any religious work, art, or history, perspective is key. It is impossible to view anything without biases. As the Ramayana is a religious work, art piece, and history depending on the viewer, it is no surprise that there are many unique interactions with the texts depending on status within the caste. The Valmiki Ramayana is steeped in gendered issues, therefore, it tracks that the upper caste Brahmin women would be given a voice to shift the story through song in an effort to make it more applicable to their state in life. This predominantly involves reclamation of power from all fronts. In a system that praises complete obedience and modesty, the women’s songs present the power in femininity, and their indispensable nature in relation to men (116). Although low-caste women are less dependent and sheltered, their songs still perpetuate empowerment through Sita and even openly detest Rama, which could be a direct rebellion against both the upper echelons of society and gendered oppression as a whole perpetuated by the caste system (132). 

This is not a solely female reclamation and challenging of the story. There are men, too, who critiqued the Ramayana and its values such as E.V.R (176). When the caste system manipulated political life, presenting a Brahmin’s versus everyone else superiority in the early 1900s, E.V.R, aware of such disparity, openly challenged the entire nature of religion (177). Consequently, those who are not of the elite, women in general, or all those of lesser status than the top rung, have found reinterpretations, or fault in the dominating political and spiritual Hinduism (179). 



271 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: challenging the system

by Deleted user -
I think you make some really great points here, Cosette. It is interesting to see just how many power dynamics are at play in both the Ramayana and Hindu culture: it's not only gender hierarchy struggles but its caste struggles as well. Because it is a text that has been prevalent for so long, it makes sense that these different groups of people who are repressed have taken the story and made it their own, gleaning different knowledge than the more highly favored classes. I am glad they have been able to reinterpret this text rather than having to flat out reject it for not speaking to their experience.

109 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: challenging the system

by Collin Cortinas -
Cosette,
Good stuff here. I love what you say about how the critique of the text is not limited to women, and how when the caste system is as manipulative as it is, these conflicts are bound to pop up. Something that came to mind while I was reading was, is the only goal here with different interpretations and challenges empowerment? What else could people of different economic situations be trying to get out of pushing the boundaries of the text the way that they seem to do?

88 words