Caste Discussion

Caste Discussion

by Collin Cortinas -
Number of replies: 5

I think caste would clearly affect how one interprets the Ramayana since throughout many religions the ways that people interpret the prominent texts stem from their social and economic situation. In one of the readings that discuss Brahmin versus non-Brahmin women singing songs about the Ramayana, and how women's songs, in general, tend to differ from those of men when it came to the religious text. Women's songs would be about things such as "pregnancy, morning sickness, childbirth, the tender love of a husband, the affections of parents-in-law, games played by brides and grooms in wedding rituals" (119). Although this specific example is talking about men and women, I think that the same differences would easily apply to people in different economic statuses within the Caste system. Drawing from my own experience, people in different economic situations have always focused on different things in the Christian Scriptures. My family being lower-middle-class in a town that was almost entirely upper class, we saw the differences easily; my family and I clung to the verses about God helping people through their problems, verses that talk about how money is not everything, etc. Our neighboring families in the upper class tended to focus much more on how God wants his people to be fruitful and provide for themselves, how important it is for more fortunate people to help those who need help, etc. The differences were clear. 

234 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Caste Discussion

by Deleted user -
Collin, I really like how you added a personal perspective. This is an example that further supports how peoples' backgrounds can create various interpretations. When reading, one will always have subconscious insight that will cause them to relate themselves to the stories or songs.

44 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Caste Discussion

by Deleted user -
Collin, I love that you included a personal anecdote that exemplifies how the caste system can compare to the economic system in America. Everyone's personal experiences will contribute to the way they read and interpret something regardless of what those experiences are which is important to keep in mind.

49 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Caste Discussion

by Cole Myers -
I definitely think that the personal addition helps here. The death of the author leaves it all up to interpretation. All people will contribute something else to a narrative's interpretation. Different classes and castes, genders, ethnicities, etc. will by nature have different interpretations of things based on experience.

48 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Caste Discussion

by Deleted user -
Hey Collin! I really like how you connected the Ramayana and the caste system to Christianity and different socioeconomic systems in America. It definitely shows how different verses/parts of stories are emphasized by different people! I wonder what parts of the Ramayana are significant for each caste. For example, perhaps the instances where Sita is emphasized as being a submissive wife is more significant for the upper class? This raises some interesting questions!

74 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Caste Discussion

by Deleted user -
The personal side that you added definitely made me think of how it could be experienced through an Indian perspective. People in different "working classes" here in America definitely use what scripture parallels with them most as I'm sure people who use the Ramayana as a parallel for their life do the same. Especially being from the south where we are in such a Bible belt people use different aspects of theology to help them cope with their particular goings on.

81 words