Discussion Week 9

Discussion Week 9

by Collin Cortinas -
Number of replies: 5

For Tuesday's readings, the main theme in our readings is the idea of using religious figures in order to make political ends meet. A shockingly recent and prevalent example of this comes in the attempt by the Indian Government and the RSS to tie Hindu religious text and historical fact together culturally. Since the story of Rama is so well-known and is very prevalent to millions of people, it is easy to divide people when you put their religious text on a political pedestal. This idea is so problematic because it casts aside the idea of multiculturalism, or the respect of different belief systems regardless of national identity. The RSS simply “wants Muslims to live in India as second-class citizens.” This type of political and religious polarization in a nation that is already suffering greatly from large economic divides is going to cause lasting damage to the overall well-being of the nation, I am certain. 

For Thursday, the political narrative of "first-class Hindu citizenship" is disrupted by writings about the major contributions that Muslims have made to the academic community of the Ramayana. There are examples such as Tamil Nadu, who, despite being a Muslim, is well respected for his work in scholarship for the Ramayana. It is said that “Hindu communities in the diaspora as well have honored Ismail” (279). This is a direct contradiction to the climate that the RSS wishes to create within India. Besides trying to prove the cultural superiority of their beliefs, it is clear that discord among religious communities is expected and Nadu breaks that expectation. 

262 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Discussion Week 9

by Deleted user -
Hey Collin, great discussion here! I was also immediately struck by the problematic aim of the RSS to use Hindu religious texts to divide people and establish a hierarchy in Indian culture. It is always disheartening when religious texts such as the Ramayana are appropriated for political gain, especially in a way that puts down another class of people. It's unfortunate, but we see this in so many religions, including Christianity, which is the most familiar religion to many of us. Though the use of the Ramayana and other religious texts in this way may benefit Hinduism in the present by establishing it as the correct religion made of first class people, this is ultimately a distortion of this text that has been beloved for so long and can result in more negative connotations of these texts in the future.

140 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Discussion Week 9

by Deleted user -
Collin and Rachel, you both made great points. When reading about the issues that arise when analyzing a religious text, I became troubled and confused. I shouldn't have been entirely confused, though, cause as you said, Rachel, this problem appears in other religions, as well. As a religious text, I would assume it would encourage that particular religion to welcome all people and faiths, but it does quite the opposite. It creates a realm of superiority and violence, which is ironic and disappointing to me. This only creates lasting complications, when, ultimately, I wish it would create lasting cooperation and unity.

101 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Discussion Week 9

by Deleted user -
Sam,
Yes, I agree. It seems that when religion is placed at the head of a society, then the culture becomes more exclusive instead of inclusive. Thinking through history, I believe it occurs more times than not. The danger of leading from and finding identity in a religious text is the room for interpretation. People are creative; they can make any religious text say anything in the right light. I think it all boils down to power, and religion is a strong tool. If you control someones heart than their politics and money will likely follow.

96 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Discussion Week 9

by Deleted user -
Collin, I agree that putting religious texts on a pedestal is sure to cause polarization within a community that will ultimately be toxic and creates conflict that goes beyond what can be handled on an individual level. I found it interesting that Muslims have made great contributes to the interpretation of the Ramayana yet are still treated as second-class citizens for not believing in it as a religious text themselves.

70 words

In reply to Collin Cortinas

Re: Discussion Week 9

by Deleted user -
I like how you pointed out tying the religious texts and politics can be catastrophic. Even if we have undenying proof that our religion and beliefs are historical fact and true, why should everyone else be forced to believe the same? If we force our beliefs on people then we miss the point of free will. God gave us free will to choose what we believe and when we try to make others suffer because we believe that is right, that is where we cross the line of stripping away a gift that God gave us. That is when we fall.

101 words