Week 9

Week 9

by Deleted user -
Number of replies: 4

The Ramayana has been used for political ends through the belief in Rama himself. If he is considered the national leader of Ayodhya then it is logical that all of the politics of the area will be based around the belief in him (Udayakumar 12). The belief in the Ramayana itself is not problematic, but when it comes to mandating that the Ramayana be looked at as a factual, historical resource without regard for other viewpoints or opinions, it becomes controversial (Jain). Sharma argues that if the Quran and Bible are being used as a historical reference, then there is no reason to exclude the Ramayana; however, we must acknowledge that it is dangerous to use religious texts as factual, historical references without examining the biases and storytelling incorporated into those works (Jain). It is problematic to regard the Ramayana as a political text because it erases political neutrality and promotes a bias from which it is impossible to escape.

There is not as large of a divide between Muslims and Hindus as Hindus perceive there to be. There are Muslims who have read and studied the Ramayana enough to be decorated scholars of the Ramayana which contrasts the view that Muslims and those of other religions are not educated on those teachings (Narayanan 277). In fact, Ismail said that in every generation there has been at least one Muslim who was an authority on this topic (Narayanan 279).


239 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 9

by Deleted user -
Olivia, you make a great point referencing how the divide between Muslims and Hindus is not as large as some may think. If this was acknowledged more often, I believe there would be less animosity between the two faiths, which will benefit many.

43 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 9

by Deleted user -
Olivia! Great thoughts. I really like how you pointed out the issues of regarding the Ramayana as a political text. Personally, we have seen in America of using religious texts as a means of creating political opinions or political basis and the dangers of that. You are spot on when you say "it erases political neutrality."

56 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 9

by Deleted user -
Olivia, this is so interesting! You are right, it's interesting to see these scholars when the RSS is trying to remove them from the narrative. It definitely complicates it when you see these scholars who are so well versed in the Ramayana. I think it can be very dangerous when we use religious texts as our only backing for a political standpoint. I think it's a good thing to understand a lot of different viewpoint through understanding these other texts.

80 words

In reply to Deleted user

Re: Week 9

by Collin Cortinas -
Olivia,
Some great stuff here! I love how you touched particularly on the focus on Rama himself, I think that is important to understanding the whole picture. Also, what you said about the troubles with using religious texts as sources of historical fact is very interesting, I think understanding the biases we all carry when it comes to this text is very important and you did well to bring it up.

71 words